Why didn't the original Death Star's shields protect against small fighters? When the torpedo strikes an object, the torpedo breaks up, the matter and antimatter meet, and you get a big kaboom. According to the graphic that @Django Reinhardt created I don't see those adjustment boosters, at least they're not obvious. To be fair though, in the old games even the Advanced Proton Torpedos couldn't turn like that. They can usually be evaded fairly easily but can nearly destroy most starfighters with one hit. And the display on the targeting computer seems to reinforce this as more of an optimal firing range rather than a target to lock on. Is there a canon explanation for why Star Trek ships bank when turning? Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Besides, if you can maneuver at 72000 g, you probably don't need a warhead . I always assumed that the Torpedoes were 'sucked' in. Maybe George Lucas could fix this issue in one last "Special Edition"? If you have at least one "CRIT' in your Pool, you resolve the effect - the effect you may choose if you have a Black Crit and Assault Proton Torpedoes is "DEAL ONE FACE UP DAMAGE CARD" NOTE. Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. The Essential Guide to Weapons and Technology describes the Energy Envelope as a... "Protective energy envelope to prevent accidental detonation caused The target is only two meters across. I've agreed to be the spokesperson for a new line of performance enhancing drugs. How can I make my companion focus on healing another player? Is there any evidence in Canon for how long specific hyperspace trips actually take in the Star Wars galaxy? That might make sense when you're writing something, but it's obviously harder to ignore the laws of inertia when someone asks you to animate it. Once locked onto a starship, the missiles follow the target in an attempt to cause damage. Very confusing. Based on this question: Why did Luke need a targeting computer in the first place? In the old Marvel Comics version of Star Wars I think you would have been rewarded a No-Prize. Given the high speed of the fighters, it seems even the computers couldn't postulate the ideal firing time correctly. Proton torpedoes have been seen in illustration to have a gyroscopic guidance system. C++ syntax understanding issue for 'using'. (You may interpret it differently, though.). Is there any official/semi-official standard for music symbol visual appearance? The Rebel fleet is the immune system and consists of spaceships that shoot 'proton torpedoes' at the Death Star, such as X-wing and Y-wing starfighters that could represent the B … Noting their apparently strange behaviour in the original movie, it seems that most EU authors have imagined Proton Torpedoes to be simple homing missiles with the additional ability of manual remote control. Of course, that's just one canon. Please note that "programmed to turn in advance by X-Wing's targeting computer" is not an answer, as I'm looking specifically for what the mechanism for ability to execute the turn, NOT why the turn happened when it happened. Is there a good alternative word to “performance” to describe a music team's actions? Torpedoes use one of two techniques for propulsion: Batteries and an electric motor -- This is the same technique that any non-nuclear submarine must use when running underwater. So, practically speaking, the pilot needs to get the torpedoes close enough to the vent to prevent them from being countermeasured or otherwise done away with, and then the internal guidance programming would take over. TIE Defender 3. Edit: After obtaining and using them, I can verify that Killer's answer is also somewhat correct. Rebel 1.1. Photon torpedoes are secondary missile weapons used by the starships of the United Federation of Planets. Correct, right click the shielded target (capital ship shield generators) until lock then release right click to fire HOWEVER you (currently as of patch 1.1) cannot fire regular missiles against these targets if you have Protons. So it seems likely that the port was venting matter of some kind that could have created a pressure differential sucking those torpedoes down. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. For example, the aforementioned Jedi Trial states that Proton Torpedoes were first used in the "Clones Wars", yet Anakin's big yellow Starfighter at the end of The Phantom Menace is said to be equipped with them. What is the best use of Warzone Commendations (for PVP purposes) after reaching Battlemaster (Valor Rank 60)? In Star Wars, is there a pretend-science explanation of how lightsabers work (like midi-chlorians for The Force)? :) (Just kidding, please don't kill me.). A POWERFUL weapon in the arsenals of the major powers of Star Trek. Originally the word torpedo referred to any explosive charge, including the type of weapon now known as a mine (q.v. Strategies to avoid being underleveled as a F2P in SW:TOR? How worried should I be about this cough? 1 New Rule 2 Card Text 3 Rules Clarification 4 Attributes 5 Available Through 6 Timing With Armada 1.5 published in December 2020 this card's effect and cost have been changed. G-1A (with Title) 3.4. What do you roll to sleep in a hidden spot? How did Luke Skywalker learn the ways of the Force so quickly? Deactivate the homing system. Stack Exchange network consists of 176 Q&A communities including Stack Overflow, the largest, most trusted online community for developers to learn, share their knowledge, and build their careers. This was changed from the book version, as the pilots were originally told that they would have to approach the exhaust port at a precise 90 degree angle, precisely fire the torpedoes, then veer away before crashing into the death star itself, both of which are what made it near impossible save for the most skilled pilots, especially while being pursued by Tie Fighters, avoiding turbo laser fire, etc. Term to describe paradox where those with less subject matter expertise can sometimes make better teachers? Your cursor must remain over the target the entire time. Although thinking about it, the port is an exhaust port. by collisions with debris or near misses by laser cannon blasts". This is different from regular missiles where you can just single click or drag over top without remaining over the target. ), however, they are treated differently yet again: More like standard slow-but-powerful homing missiles, with no manual guidance. Wait... Use the force, Luke. If the exhaust port is perpendicular to the surface of the Death Star, why not fly straight towards it instead of along the trench? What's the difference between the space torpedoes ---> armoured torpedoes ---> devastator torpedoes chain and the proton torpedoes ---> neutron torpedoes chain? Is a comment aligned with the element being commented a good practice? Well I will give an answer just based on I haven't seen this answer appear on this page yet, at least not as I interpreted the question. March 2021 Topic Challenge: Cornelia Funke, Audience-specific texts for custom close reasons: Scientific Solutions or…. Now the Advanced Missles, those were pretty awesome. There are like 5 or 7 layers of canon in SW Universe. Propose future topics for SFF topic challenges! How canon is Star Wars: Battlefront (2015)? To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. There are five cannons that, currently, did not make it into 2.0: ARC Caster, Autoblaster, Flechette, Linked Battery, Mangler. In Star Trek land, the photon torpedoes have a section of matter, and a section of antimatter (both held in magnetic suspension). Use line-of-sight guidance system. Guided ordnance in space would have the same mechanics of a simple shuttle as far as maneuvering is concerned. It only takes a minute to sign up. Former PI lists a non-contributor as first author on a manuscript for which I did all the work. They can blow a ship to dust when used against an unshielded target. (The Proton Torpedoes were dumb missiles that travelled in a straight line), I don't really see how something venting matter could ever create a suction :), If the system is closed, how does my proton torpedo get down into the reactor? Note that I said 5 above — Killer's assertion that there are never more than 4 targets you can use the torpedoes on is incorrect, especially since there is more than one ultra-ship in some missions. Next steps? In the fourth draft (the one just prior to filming) of the script, Lucas gives us a hint about how he envisioned the Proton Torpedoes working: DODONNA Your approach will not be easy. as in programmed to turn after say 100m ? Arqade is a question and answer site for passionate videogamers on all platforms. Physics students have boldly gone where no student has gone before -- by calculating one way to potentially build photon torpedoes seen in the Star Trek universe. Some interplay between a torpedo and Death Star's technology as TangoOversway's answer to that question alluded to being a possibility? Since we can disregard the Payload, the Ignition Charge and the Homing Sensor as being the means by which the torpedo can turn, it stands to reason that it's either the Propellant Cylinder or the Energy Envelope Projector that allow tight maneuvering. Later in the movie, when Luke actually fires his Proton Torpedoes into the Death Star, we see them shoot straight into the distance, and then "drop" into the exhaust vent. Does it mean that the weapon will undo any damage it does to shields or will it actualy just fix a targets shields when it hits? Inclusion of an idecomposable module in the direct sum of two copies always split? In general, proton torpedoes are armed for light targets only, and are only useful for pinpoint attacks on vessels whose shields have already been dropped by capital ship weapons. If I have a chance to look through one of the Star Wars Tech manuals I will check it out. Its most notable use was during the Battle of Yavin, when Luke Skywalker destroyed the first Death Star by launching a pair of proton torpedoes into a thermal exhaust port. Forcefields from an X-Wing? Is there a canon explanation for how Proton Torpedoes were able to turn 90 degrees at the end of Star Wars: ANH. In the alternate reality, the advanced long-range torpedoes were a type of photon torpedo developed by Starfleet in 2258 as part of the preparations for a war with the Klingon Empire. Thanks for contributing an answer to Arqade! Because of the long lock-on >>delay, you may want to unequip the torpedoes entirely prior to some missions - they >>aren't great against fast-disappearing capital ships. From the descriptions they all seem to do the same thing - ignore shield/deflector … I'm sure the computer could have figured out the exact time.. but the real question would be whether or not a human could react with the same precision and push the button at that Precise moment. Can you provide any references to back up what appears to be a conjecture ? Photons, actually, have nothing to do … "I said the port wasn't particle-shielded. How were Anakin, Obi-Wan, and Palpatine physically trapped by a ray shield? The proton torpedo was a type of ordnance used throughout the galaxy. Why does water weaken ion ion attractions? If there is only a 1/5th of a second margin for error, then probably no one save for someone with Jedi skills and force powers could do that, hence the reason why Luke was probably the only one that could do it. takes place in outer space. People walk inside due to artificial gravity of some kind, because the floors are flat instead of curved. Point in case is that having Proton missiles allows you to one shot shielded targets saving the time of wearing down these targets with lasers and missiles. Wookieepedia states (without attribution) that proton torpedoes have the ability to turn 90 degrees inside of a meter, with an accompanying image of just what you're talking about. According to the Star Wars: Blueprints - Rebel Edition factbook, The Proton Torpedo consists of four primary components; A Propellant Cylinder, an Energy Envelope Projector, an Ignition Charge and a Homing Sensor (along with the Explosive Payload, obviously). However, it is completely ray-shielded. site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. This merely seems to be a question of converting horizontal inertia to vertical movement. I have not come across a specific mention in the books or any other source material I have read as to what the exact MECHANISM is on how or why the torpedoes were able to turn 90 degree's, but they are target lock homing weapons. The value of the trench is that you can approach at the safest, least gun-covered point on the surface, then have only the few guns along the trench able to hit you on your way to the target. Is there an in-canon explanation for how “manual” hyperspace exits are possible? Is it feasible to circumnavigate the Earth in a sailplane? This is why when they showed the targeting computers you saw the two vertical lines closing and the distance counting down to firing time. Can you cast Call Lightning while submerged underwater? Why did Luke need a targeting computer in the first place? Roadside / Temporary fix for skipping chain. They're not too terribly effective against shields, though, being an explosive. Indeed, if you slow down the infamous shot in question, you can see that the animator seemed want the torpedoes to appear to be falling... it's the just animation happens too quickly you don't see it. In comparison, during that same period, Earth's Starfleet was still employing the spatial torpedo, although they soon upgraded to photonic torpedoes, the precursors to the photon torpedo. Something of Proton Torpedoes can radiate through the physical shielding most ships have against things like meteors and stuff to do energy type damage to a hull and Concussion Missles do quiet a bit of damage generally because they're like modern day concussion grenades blah blah blah. The warhead of a photon torpedo can be removed and replaced by sensor packages or other equipment. Ancient temple booby traps designed for dragons, Sci-fi film where an EMP device is used to disable an alien ship, and a huge robot rips through a gas station. The shields on the smaller ships can't be targeted with the torpedoes. Klingons began using photon torpedoes by at least the mid-22nd century. Translation of lucis mortiat / reginae gloriae. Seems to me, when Luke opened himself to the Force, it not only told him where to shoot, but when. I mean, you've got deflectors and dampeners which negate the concussion. Do not unequipt them for any reason (not necessary). Perhaps some complex pump system causes a pressure differential after exhausting waste gas. It's FAR from canon, but in the old X-Wing and Tie Fighter games, proton torpedoes were target seeking weapons with their own guidance systems. Absolutely wrong. A Proton Torpedo Launcher carries a Starship's Proton Torpedo payload. Yes, I always thought they were sucked in after playing Rogue Squadron. TL;DR: Equip your proton missiles and use them 1 per target that allows it. However you have a max of 4 Protons and ALL MISSIONS that have the possibility of firing these Proton missiles have no more than the max of 4 targets to fire at. Naval-technology.com lists the world’s most advanced torpedoes based on performance characteristics such as speed, range and operating depth. Inclusion of an idecomposable module in the direct sum of two copies always split? So that's my first point. Learn the secret behind the destructive power of a photon torpedo! From a scientific point of view, the exhaust shaft operates as an effective vacuum before actually expelling any waste gasses, so any solid objects (proton torpedoes having a physical casing as well as an energy charge) would have been 'sucked' into the shaft by that vacuum if the shot was timed correctly which his use of he force would enable. This is more likely born out of the need for gaming mechanics, however. Why Did the Rebels Have to Fly Along the Death Star Trench? It only takes a minute to sign up. Incidentally releasing clouds of protons, because that’s what’s in clouds of anything, is clearly not the idea behind proton torpedoes nor the spirit of this question. (With this interpretation, Luke turning off his targeting computer allowed him to manually guide the missiles down the exhaust port.). What was the thermal exhaust port on the first Death Star venting? To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers. You must maneuver straight in down this shaft, level off in the trench and skim the surface to this point. I found a .pdf of a second edition of the Star Wars Sourcebook by West End Games, which states that in their section on armaments, "Proton Torpedoes...Unlike heavier space bombardments used by turbolasers mounted in immense Star Destroyers, these weapons are effective against ray and energy shielded targets...Proton torpedoes carry a proton-scattering energy warhead.". Torpedoes are the most preferred lethal underwater weapons for naval platforms such as submarines, surface vessels, aircraft and helicopters. The Death Star is too light to have significant gravity. These don’t work on VTOL planes because of the way laser projectors work. Lacking a guidance system, it stands to reason that the torpedoes had a preprogrammed trajectory already established. a little rocket booster would have to be turned on mid-flight to correct the direction of the warhead (objects in space will continue to move in a straight line unless acted on by a force (Newton's first law)). A standard Proton Torpedo Launcher holds three Proton Torpedoes (See below). The screen time is so short, the eye creates the illusion of a sharp turn. E.g., was it some capability of torpedoes' propulsion? Luke used the force to guide his decision making process on how to move and when to fire, NOT to nudge the torpedos for which he was woefully undertrained (see his training with Yoda). The (now deleted) answer he quotes was actually also correct — you can't use regular missiles on a heavily-shielded target unless (a) you are out of proton torpedoes or (b) you have fired a torpedo and it has not yet hit its target. How do you vent heat into space without venting gas? @DjangoReinhardt - Possibly of interest to you; 'thermal exhaust port' - it vents waste heat, not necessarily gas. The target is only two meters across. as the means by which the torpedo can execute turns, guided by the homing sensor. It's really not much better than a regular 3-dice attack with either focus or target lock to modify the dice. Unless the Death Star has an artificial atmosphere, which was not alluded to in the movies, that would mean that the trajectory of the proton torpedoes in question at least until entering the thermal vent shaft would take place in a vacuum.
Cemetery Plots Near Me, Woodlawn Middle School Hours, Fire Safety In Residential Buildings, Rockets Man Menu, Small Scale Industries Ideas, A Man Of No Importance: Love Who You Love, Firefighter 1 Academy Oregon, California Foster Care Education Law Fact Sheet 2018, Basis Ggz Groningen, Houses For Sale In Germiston Primrose, Boy Names That Rhyme With Jackson,
